Temperature Coefficient of Resistance (TCR) for Neutral Grounding
Summary
MegaResistors manufactures Neutral Grounding Resistors that are fully compliant with the latest version of IEEE C57.32. When buying a Neutral Grounding Resistor, ask the manufacturer for the TCR of the material. If it is above 881 ppm/°C, it is not compliant with IEEE C57.32.
If you have a specification that calls for a Neutral Grounding Resistor that calls for a TCR that is much less than 881 ppm/°C, challenge the specification with this article. We’ve commonly seen specifications for 263 ppm/°C (0.000263 per degree Celsius); there is no technical reason for this requirement.
From a technical standpoint, keeping the TCR below 881 ppm/°C has no adverse impact on overcurrent coordination or relay pickup settings. Using a TCR that is too low (below 263 ppm/°C) can prevent low current faults from being detected.
Contents
- Introduction
- TCR impact on NGR resistance
- Sensitivity of ground fault current to NGR resistance
- TCR impact on Overcurrent Coordination
- TCR impact on overcurrent relays pickup setting
- Conclusions
Article
Introduction
Since 2016, an increase in demand for Neutral Grounding Resistors (NGR’s) with a Temperature Coefficient of Resistance (TCR) equal or lower than 263 ppm/°C has been observed.
This requirement comes as a result of the new version of IEEE Standard 32 published in 2016 as C57.32. Paragraph 7.3 of this standard states: “…The TCR, based on the temperature interval of 30°C to 790°C, shall not exceed 0.000263 per degree Celsius. This is to help ensure that the final fault current has a value sufficiently high to allow protective relays to function as intended.”
IEEE Standard 32 was originally developed by the Neutral Grounding Subcommittee of the IEEE Power Engineering Society. The new version C57.32-2016 was produced by the Transformers Committee of the IEEE Power and Energy Society.
The controversy started immediately after the new version was published. Existing practice and even application standards such as IEEE Standard C62.92.3 (referred to in C57.32) accepted TCRs of more than 1000 ppm/°C for 10 and 60 second resistors, and 200 ppm/°C for continuously rated NGRs.
Restricting the TCR to 263 ppm/°C for time-rated resistors was not only unnecessary, it could result in more expensive and larger resistors while providing no practical advantages to the end user.
To deal with this problem, a working group was formed by the Transformers Committee of the IEEE Power and Energy Society, and after further review by industry experts, the group decided unanimously to change the requirement to 0.000881 per degree C (881 ppm/°C) in amendment C57.32a.
TCR Impact on NGR Resistance
The TCR, which is demonstrated by a describes the relative change in resistance associated with a given change in temperature and is defined by the following equation:
a = ( 1/R ) \Delta R / \Delta T (1)
If a does not vary too much with temperature, a linear approximation can be used to estimate the NGR resistance R at any temperature T knowing the resistance at the initial temperature Ti.
R = Ri + \alpha Ri ( T – Ti ) (2)
Some low power applications in instrumentation such as current sensing devices require a very low TCR while others such as temperature measurement instruments need a very high TCR. On the other hand, high power applications such as harmonic filter resistors demand a low TCR while grounding resistors can allow the use of alloys with a moderate TCR. Typical ranges for TCRs in different applications as well as some widely used materials for NGR construction are shown in the following table:
Table-1- Typical TCR used for different applications.
Current | Application | TCR, ppm/°C |
Low | Instrumentation, Current Sensing | 2 – 100 |
Very Low | Instrumentation, Temperature Measurement | 2000 – 7000 |
Medium | Harmonic Filters | 100 – 500 |
Medium | Neutral Grounding, High Resistance | 100 – 250 |
High | Neutral Grounding, Low Resistance | 100 – 1500 |
Table-2- Typical alloys used to manufacture high-resistance NGRs.
Alloy Groups | TCR ppm/°C | % / 385°C | Common use |
Nichrome | 170 | 6.5 | Continuous ratings (High Resistance) |
FeCrAl | 100 | 3.9 | Continuous ratings (High Resistance) |
Table-3- Typical alloys used to manufacture low-resistance NGRs.
Alloy | TCR ppm/°C | % / 760°C | Common use |
Stainless Steel 430 | 1380 | 105 | 10s and 60s ratings (Low Resistance) |
Stainless Steel 304 | 1050 | 80 | 10s and 60s ratings (Low Resistance) |
Stainless Steel 316 | 940 | 71 | 10s and 60s ratings (Low Resistance) |
IEEE limit | 881 | 67 | 10s and 60s ratings (Low Resistance) |
Mega Resistors material | 414 | 31 | 10s and 60s ratings (Low Resistance) |
Continuously rated resistors can have temperature rises of up to 385°C. Commonly used materials with a TCR of up to 241 ppm/°C would have increases in resistance of up to 9.3% resulting in a decrease in the neutral current of up to 8.5%.
Time rated resistors for 10s and 60s can have temperature rises of up to 760°C. Materials with TCR of 881 ppm/°C would have increases in resistance of 67% resulting in a decrease in the neutral current of 40%.
As mentioned in IEEE Standard C62.92.3, the resistance change in 10s or 60s rated resistors may be negligible for a fault cleared within a few cycles. However, if breaker failure is experienced, and backup relays are called into play to ensure proper tripping, the resistor tolerance and increased resistance must be included in the coordination analysis. It should be noted that the neutral current decrease due to TCR has no impact on coordination. In fact, it even inherently helps to have a better coordination between two cascaded short circuit interrupters. The impact of TCR on overcurrent coordination and tripping time will be explained in detail in this report.
Having analyzed the TCR from the NGR perspective, now we can do so from the power system point of view.
Sensitivity of Ground Fault Current to NGR Resistance
The main purpose of NGRs is reducing Single-Line-to-Ground (SLG) fault current. In this section, it will be shown that the changes in ground fault current due to temperature impact on NGR resistance does not cause a noticeable influence on protection coordination.
The following assumptions have been made when conducting the analysis:
- In low resistance grounded systems, residual current is used by ground protective relays, not the neutral current.
- In high resistance grounded systems, ground fault current coordination is not required.
- NGR resistance changes impact on neutral current, but ground current is affected to a lesser extent.
In order to demonstrate the sensitivity of the ground fault current to NGR resistance, let’s assume an SLG fault at terminals of a generator, as shown in Figure-1.
Figure 1 – Connection diagram of a generator or transformer experiencing a SLG fault.
In order to drive the ground fault current, the sequence networks analysis technique is used. First, the sequence network is obtained, as shown in Figure-2. The ground fault current is then derived as below:
If = 3 x VPH / (Z1 + Z2 + Z0 + 3 Rf + (3 Rn Xc) / (3 Rn + Xc)) (3)
where,
If Single-Line-to-Ground (SLG) fault current at the point of fault P
VPH Nominal phase voltage at source terminals, no load connected, just before the occurrence of the fault. A Source is considered to be a Transformer or a Generator.
Z1 Direct impedance measured from the source’s Neutral up to the point P
Z2 Inverse impedance measured from the source’s Neutral up to the point P
Z0 Homopolar impedance measured from the source’s Neutral up to the point P, and from P back to the source’s Neutral, but this time following the ground path. Note that any impedance in the Ground path has to be multiplied by 3.
Rf Resistance at the point of fault.
Rn NGR Neutral resistor, the objective of this report.
Xc Grid leakage capacitance per phase
According to Equation (3), it is clear that:
- The fault Current If is composed of many parameters and basically depends on the grounding system.
- Neutral current Ir (through the NGR) and Capacitive charging current Iccc (through feeders) do not appear explicitly in the formula.
In addition, it can be shown through symmetrical components that the relation between If, Ir and Iccc is as follows:
I_f=\sqrt(I_r\\^2 + I_{ccc}\\^2) (4)
Note that Ir and Iccc are 90 degrees apart.
In the following sections, Equation (3) will be analyzed for NGRs for high resistance and low resistance grounding systems.
High Resistance Grounding (HRG) Systems
The main objective of HRG systems is reducing the magnitude of Single-Line-to-Ground fault current and related overvoltages as much as possible, thus allowing the power grid to keep on working temporarily. HRG systems are typically used in low voltage power grids, from 480VAC up to 600VAC, and in some cases up to 5kVAC.
The resistor value is chosen such that:
- Ir (through the NGR) is higher than the system capacitive charging current Iccc (on the line side),
- At the same time, If (at point P) is lower than a certain maximum limit, typically 10A, as specified by Canadian Electric Code (CEC), CSA.C22.1-2018.
These two criteria help define the usable resistor range. It is required to know or estimate the system capacitive charging current. These constraints are derived from the following conditions of the power systems.
First, wherever a line voltage unbalance of certain magnitude is present, a net capacitive charging current Iccc leaks from all over the power grid to ground. One of the causes behind these types of voltage unbalances is precisely the single-line-to-ground faults.
There exist two possible explanations behind assuring the current through the resistor Ir is to be larger than the capacitive charging current Iccc: In fact, if Ir is larger than Iccc, the risk of unfaulted feeders tripping due to some capacitive contribution, called sympathetic tripping, is eliminated. It is required to set the pickup value of any ground current feeder relay above Iccc, but below Ir, so that the relay will be able to discriminate between If and Iccc. Consider that If is always larger than Ir. A typical multi-feeder high resistance grounded system is shown below.
Figure 2 – Connection diagram of a high resistance grounded generator supplying two feeders.
If Ir is larger than Iccc, or Rn is smaller than Xc, then line over-voltages are reduced
It is important to limit the power dissipation at the point of fault P. Otherwise the fault may evolve into a two- or three-phase fault thus tripping the feeder circuit breaker and spoiling the HRG system. One of the advantages of HRG systems is that the energy involved in the fault is mostly dissipated in a protected environment, i.e. the NGR.
Considering the ground fault resistance negligible or zero, the Equation (3) is simplified as below:
If = 3 x VPH / (Z1 + Z2 + Z0 + (3 Rn Xc) / (3 Rn + Xc)) (5)
Sequence impedances of distribution transformers, generators and lines are comparatively small and mostly inductive meaning that their influence on the ground fault current in HRG systems (mostly resistive) is minimal and may be excluded when calculating the fault current.
An HRG system can be achieved by zig-zag grounding transformer where the neutral point of the power system is not available.
Equation [3] result in:
If = 3 x VPH / (3 Rn Xc) / (3 Rn + Xc) (6)
If = VPH x ( 3 Rn + Xc) / (3 Rn Xc) (7)
If = VPH x ( 3 / Xc + 1 / 3 Rn) (8)
As may be realized, for higher Xc values, Rn variations due to temperature become more evident and on the contrary, lower Xc values may mask those variations.
Note that the formula used for designing HRG systems considers Ir instead of If, not taking into account the influence of the capacitive charging current.
Ir = VPH / Rn (9)
Small variations of Rn may have an impact on Ir although it is important to emphasize that ground fault current coordination is not required for High Resistance Grounding systems since the neutral overcurrent protection relays work with definite time trip time. (Inverse time is used too).
In case of using a zig-zag grounding transformer to obtain an artificial neutral point for resistance grounding the system:
- The zig-zag connection is installed in the ground fault current return path, so their impedance corresponds to the zero sequence. This statement is not true. The zig-zag transformer is installed between lines and the neutral.
- The zero-sequence impedance is mostly resistive due to its design.
Equation (3) may be written as:
If = 3 x VPH / (Z0 + (3 Rn Xc) / (3 Rn + Xc)) (9)
Zig-zag transformer zero sequence impedance is typically around 20 to 30 ohms, and when weighed against (3 Rn Xc) / (3 Rn + Xc), it may be around 10% of this value, for instance when considering Rn = 70 ohms, and Xc = -j1000 ohms.
Figure 3 – Connection diagram of a high resistance grounded generator via zig-zag grounding transformer.
In HRG Systems, the impact of inserting a zig zag transformer is comparable to the effect of increasing resistance due to temperature. In both cases, since both effects are predictable, they may be compensated by reducing the nominal value of Rn accordingly.
Low Resistance Grounded (LRG) Systems
The objective of LRG systems is reducing single-line-to-ground fault current level to values around 10% of the available 3-Phase Short Circuit Current, or from 50A to 1000A depending on the application. LRG systems are typically used in Medium Voltage (MV) power grids and protection relays are designed to trip in a short time, typically less than 1 second.
The behavior of the LRG power system in case of a single-line-to-ground fault is quite different from the case of HRG. Equation (3) applies to LRG systems, however, a comprehensive analysis should be carried out from the Point of Connection with the Utility down into each of the feeders. Further, the following information must be provided:
- Utility short circuit data (three-phase and single-phase)
- HV/MV transformer parameters
- Zig-zag transformer parameters (if applicable)
- MV Line overcurrent relays trip settings
This analysis requires the following steps:
- Grid Z1/Z2 It is assumed Z1 = Z2.
- Grid Z0 calculation
- Transformer HV/MV calculation
- Selection of single-line-to-ground fault at MV levels to achieve proper coordination with utility overcurrent relays
- Build sequence Impedance circuit under single-line-to-ground fault condition
- Calculation of Rn
- Verification of If at MV level
Common practice in the industry for calculating the value of Rn, the following formula is typically applied:
Rn = VPH / Ir (10)
The same equation was used for HRG systems.
One might question the difference from HRG system conditions. The answer lies in the fact that the fault current If is around 100 times larger than the case of HRG such that the voltage drop on Z1 and Z2 cannot be discarded. As a consequence, the available voltage applied on Rn is reduced, and so are the In and If.
To know how much reduction in fault current occurs because of voltage drop, the whole calculation based on symmetrical components has to be performed, but for 500 A it is possible to have a reduction approximately equal to 10%, and even higher when using grounding transformers.
Even in case of a Rn increase due to temperature, the ground fault coordination based on If will be kept regardless of the number of steps, if it has been properly designed according to Equation (10).
The precaution to take on significant reduction in current is preventing the unnecessary operation of line or transformer overcurrent relays either in MV or HV lines. Therefore, all the protection curves have to be drawn in the corresponding graph.
TCR Impact on Overcurrent Coordination
To demonstrate the impact of the TCR on overcurrent coordination and tripping time of overcurrent protective devices, two most widely used types of overcurrent characteristics are investigated.
Definite-Time Overcurrent Characteristics
Definite time ground overcurrent characteristics (ANSI code 50) are used for detecting ground faults much more sensitively and trip within minimum time since this element is only sensitive to ground or residual current. As shown below, both the main and backup protective devices will have a specific tripping time under this scenario, e.g. t1 for the main tripping device and t2 for the backup one.
Figure 4 – Definite time overcurrent protection devices coordination.
In this figure, the solid line shows the condition where the TCR is hypothetically zero or negligible. As such, the ground current remains unchanged resulting in tripping times of t1 and t2 by the main and backup protective devices, respectively. With a non-zero and realistic TCR value, the dashed line shows the change in ground fault current over time due to temperature rise in NGR and the consequent rise in NGR resistance. However, the tripping times are still unchanged, i.e. t1 for the main and t2 for the backup protective device. Therefore, the TCR has not impact on overcurrent coordination and tripping times of definite-time overcurrent short circuit interrupters.
Inverse Time Overcurrent Characteristics
In the second scenario, the time overcurrent protective devices are investigated. The time-current characteristics are inverse-time in this case, as shown in Figure 5.
As shown, the hypothetically negligible TCR results in tripping time t1 and t2 by the main and backup protective devices. However, with a realistic TCR, the t1 increases to t1’ which is greater than t1 by a time difference of e seconds. In the same way, the t2 increases to t2’ which is greater than t2 by a time difference of s seconds. Since the characteristics are exponential, the s is greater than the e meaning that the time interval between the trips by the main and backup overcurrent devices has increased due to the decrease in ground fault current caused by a NGR resistance increase. Therefore, the TCR helps the coordination between the main and backup inverse time overcurrent protective devices.
Figure 5 – Inverse time overcurrent protection devices coordination.
TCR Impact on Overcurrent Relays Pickup Setting
In unfaulted condition, the system charging current will not appear in the residual current because the line-to-ground system charging capacitances are assumed equal. The three currents through the three line-to-ground charging capacitances make a three-phase current set. These three currents cancel each other in the neutral, even in the residual current. In a single feeder system like the ground overcurrent of the generator, the ground overcurrent pickup setting can be lower than the total system charging current. The only thing to be noted is the negligible asymmetry of the charging capacitances that causes a continuous current through the neutral which is very small and good for NGR passive monitoring. Usually, the pickup setting is set to 20%, i.e. one-fifth of the maximum expected ground current. However, this pickup setting of 20% should be greater than the total charging current of the longest feeder in a multi-feeder configuration so that the unfaulty feeders do not trip due to their capacitive charging current. With the TCR of 881 ppm/°C recommended by IEEE C57.32a, a 40% reduction in ground fault current happens which reduces the neutral current to 60%. This current is still above the pickup setting and total system charging current. In the following section, it is shown how the TCR might cause a reset of the pickup setting of the overcurrent relays.
Definite-time overcurrent protective relays:
As long as the pickup setting is set to 20% to 60%, this kind of overcurrent protection is not affected by a TCR of as high as 881 ppm/C since the tripping time is the same for any level of ground fault current, even close to the pickup current. This does not hold true and causes some issues in case of inverse-time overcurrent relays which is explained in the following section.
Inverse-time overcurrent protective relays:
In high resistance grounded systems, the ground fault current is always equal to the nominal current of the NGR because the NGR resistance defines the fault current, and fault impedance has no capability of influencing the fault current level. With the TCR of 881 ppm/°C, the NGR current will decrease to 60% which is still very high and will be detected even if the pickup is set to 60%. Thus, no issues arise from a high TCR concerning the pickup setting.
Figure 6 – Neutral current reduction due to temperature in a high resistance grounded system protected by inverse-time ground overcurrent relays.
However, in low resistance grounded systems, the ground faults with current less than NGR let-through current are possible since the line and fault impedances are comparable to the NGR resistance. For instance, if a ground fault happens with ground current of 30% of the NGR rated current, the 760°C temperature rise of a NGR with the TCR of 881 ppm/°C will cause the ground current to decrease to 18% which is below the 20% pickup.
Figure 7 – Neutral current reduction due to temperature in a low resistance grounded system protected by inverse-time ground overcurrent relays.
In fact, with the TCR of 881 ppm/°C, any ground fault with a current less than 33% of the NGR rated current might not activate the pickup since the current reduces by 60% to just under the pickup, i.e. 20% of NGR nominal current. If a better TCR is used, e.g. 441 ppm/°C, the NGR resistance will increase by 33% decreasing the ground fault current about 25%. With the pickup setting of 20%, all the ground faults with current less than 27% might not be detected by the overcurrent relays since the 33% reduction due to temperature rise of 760°C will reduce the ground current to just under the pickup resetting the overcurrent relays. The lower TCR improved the relay performance. Lastly, using a material with 164 ppm/°C, any ground fault current with current less than 22.5% might not be detected. However, it is very unlikely in a low resistance grounded system to get a high impedance fault with only 30% of the NGR nominal current. Further, the 30% current will take a very long time to take the temperature to 760°C, maybe several minutes. For such high impedance faults, the maximum temperature experienced by the resistor is below 760°C. Further, the temperature rise is measured at hot spots of the resistors and not the entire material of the equipment meaning that the majority of the resistive elements will be at a lower temperature. As such, the resistor will show lesser resistance changes due to temperature. Under this condition, the main and backup relays will most probably trip the fault before the current decreases to below the pickup setting.
It is possible to estimate how much time it takes for a resistor to experience 760°C at various currents. Some of the parameters needed to calculate this time duration are the density, specific heat capacity, length, and diameter of the resistor apart from typical specifications of the NGR. The variation of the current through the NGR in respect to time will be derived from IEEE Std. C57.32-2015, section 7.9.4.2. To conduct this calculation, first the total dissipated heat in the resistor over time is needed to be quantified which is derived from the electrical energy absorbed by the resistor.
AU = V I t (11)
As known from thermodynamic behavior of the equipment, the thermal energy dissipated in the resistor is calculated as follows.
AU = mc\Delta T (12)
Where m is the mass of the resistor, and C is the specific hear constant. Combining these two equations, the temperature change over time is obtained.
V I t = m C\Delta T (13)
On the basis of section 7.9.4.2 of IEEE Std. C57.32-2015:
\Delta {T\ =\ }\frac{\mathrm{1}}{\alpha}\mathrm{\ }\left[\mathrm{\ -1+}\sqrt{\mathrm{1+}\frac{\mathrm{0.478\ J_0\\^2\ R_0\ \alpha\ t\ }}{\mathrm{\partial\ C}}}\mathrm{\ } \right] (14)
Substituting the Equation (14) in Equation (13), and some simplifications, the time that it takes for the current to decrease to pickup setting of 20% is achieved as below:
t\ =\ \frac{\mathrm{11.95\ \partial\ L^2\ C\ R_0\ I_0\\^2}}{\mathrm{\alpha\ V^2\ I_n\\^2\ }}\ {-\ }\frac{\mathrm{10\partial LAC }}{\mathrm {\alpha^2 \ V\ I_n}} (15)
Conclusions
On the basis of the
carried-out analysis, it is concluded that the NGR resistance change due to
temperature rise during ground faults does not have a significant impact on
ground fault current meaning that the functionality of the ground overcurrent
protective devices is not compromised. Moreover, the NGR temperature rise does
not have any adverse effect on the overcurrent coordination, and can actually
contribute towards better coordination. Lastly, it was shown that an asserted
overcurrent pickup setting is not expected to be reset due to reduction in
ground fault current due to temperature rise. As such, the new requirement of
IEEE Std. C32 Amendment C32.a for having a maximum temperature coefficient of
881 ppm/°C guarantees a secure and reliable overcurrent protection.



